May 21

Learning from First Virtual

RPM Ventures Founder & Managing Director, Marc Weiser, aka GreatLakesVC, was an entrepreneur before turning VC.  He started First Virtual (FV), a company he later took public.

Awhile ago I read FV’s white paper which explains what they did & how they did it from a managerial perspective.

What was special about FV?

To me what stood out about FV’s system, was that the financial tokens that underlie commerce (e.g. credit card numbers, bank account information), never appeared on the internet at all under FV.  Rather, they were linked to the buyer’s Virtual PIN by FV. (This is pre-encryption)

Sure there are other cool things about FV.  Read the white paper to see what stands out to you.

FV: The Virtual Company

The company’s biggest challenge was growth management.

They had no physical offices until 15 months after the company was founded (8 months after the system was operational).  The larger the company grew, the more seriously its productivity was impeded by communications difficulties, which ultimately led to the decision to consolidate the bulk of the operations (particularly new hires) in a small number of offices.  The biggest problem in running a distributed company were the more mundane aspects of any corporation – administrative tasks, scheduling meetings, making presentations to customers, etc.  It was harder to get people together for informal brainstorming sessions.  Difficult to guarantee everyone would speak with unified voice in public statements about the company.  Difficult to avoid duplicated efforts.  Harder to integrate new hires.  Actual supervision of remotely located employees was big challenge.  It is also challenging to keep up morale in a virtual environment, as it becomes easier to feel “out of touch” with the company.

Despite all the challenges with being a virtual company, the founders lived in four different parts of the country & the company could not have started any other way.

What worked best was creative projects led by small, motivated, skilled teams.  The customer support system also went well.  FV did nearly all of its customer support over the internet & customer service operators work well remotely.  FV was able to employ people with physical disabilities for its customer support team.  Training was the biggest challenge as the team grew.

By nature, any Internet service company will be somewhat “virtual” because of the need to support fully international operations.  FV recommends asking not “should an Internet company be virtual?” but asking “How virtual should an Internet company be?” & then figuring out how to maximize the benefits of a virtual company, & minimize the disadvantages.


What does this mean for you?

It could mean a lot of things.  To keep it simple, at least takeaway the following:

Do something innovative, think outside the box, work hard & be successful.

Venture on,

MEL aka Venture Gal

Enhanced by Zemanta

Mar 28

ES569: Jan Garfinkle, Arboretum Ventures Founder & Managing Director

Healthcare investing is great because beyond the possibility of generating significant returns, the companies invested in save lives & really impact people.  Yes, there are huge risks.  Huge risk, huge reward.  At this week’s class, Jan Garfinkle, Founder & Managing Director of Arboretum Ventures spoke to the class.  Jan started her career as an engineer & in 2002 founded Arboretum Ventures.  The firm celebrates its 10th birthday this year & has successfully raised 3 funds.

Jan focused her discussion on financing companies, answering common questions that entrepreneurs ask:

How does an entrepreneur figure out how much money the company needs?

  • Start with a budget.  VCs want to know what is the most important thing the company must do to increase its value (aka a milestone) & how much money will it take to reach that milestone.

How to decide which source of funds to pursue?

Consider

  • Cost. What are the cost of the funds you raise (i.e. cost in terms of ownership)?
  • Flexibility. What level of decision making responsibility do you want?
  • Supply. Where is capital available?
  • Entrepreneur’s goals long term. Do you want to build a lifestyle business that you can work at for the rest of your life?
  • Type of business.  Not all businesses are venture hackable.

What are sources of capital?

  • Yourself
  • Grants (government, foundations, universities)
  • Debt (customers, bank, venture debt)
  • Equity (friends & families & fools, angels, VC, IPO)

What do VCs look for?

A great jockey, riding a great horse, in a huge race.  In other words, a great entrepreneur, commercializing a great product, in a huge market.  Jan, like many VCs I know, prefers an A team & B product, over a B team & A product.

What do VCs do when they due diligence?

Try to learn as much as possible about tit!

  • Management
    • Track record
    • Relevant experience
    • Highly motivated
    • Honest & ethical (how are decisions made? how does the team communicate?)
    • Make sure you can recruit the right people
  • Financials & exit potential
    • capital requirements
    • exit price & timing
    • talk to strategic corporations to understand what they need to see in order to be interested in buying the company (*we at RPM don’t do this well)
  • Product need
  • Market size
  • Time to market
  • Competitive positioning
    • existing technologies
    • emerging technologies
    • IP

Material company provides & how long it takes to get the materials to the VC are indicators of how the entrepreneur will be like to work with.

What is the best way to get VCs’ attention?

Get a warm introduction/referral!

In addition to the insights Jan shared in response to those particular questions, she also shared a few notable quotables:

  • “Your career will not be a straight line. Be flexible”
  • “If it’s a great exit, every body wins. Even the janitor if he got shares”
  • “The more touch points you’ve had as problems the more successful you’re be as a CEO”
Selecting investment opportunities & selecting funders involves building relationships.  Getting to know each other.  Building trust.  Even if you are a great jockey, with a fast horse, in a huge race, if the investor doesn’t trust you, or you don’t trust the investor – that’s not a good way to start an investor/entrepreneur relationship.

Way to go Jan!  Keep up the great work & Venture On,

MEL aka Venture Gal

Mar 22

ES569: People and Culture featuring Serial Entrepreneur Josh Pokempner

Tuesday night’s class focused on People & Culture, the most important part of any organization (in my opinion).  Our guest speaker was Josh Pokempner, serial entrepreneur & founder of several successful companies.  Below are some of my raw notes for that night’s discussion with Josh:

  • Business is trying to control circumstances so intended results happen.  my response:  life is trying to control circumstances to intended results happen.
  • we can’t control how well a product does, but we can control our corporate culture.
  • how to create that great culture?
    • servant leadership
      • rich person = someone so in love with what they do, so much they can’t wait to get out of bed to do it. can’t wait for alarm to go off so you can get out of bed. my response: what is it that i can’t wait for? what is it that makes me wish my alarm will go off?!
    • create & practice a shared mission, vision & values
    • “5 ways of being”
  • book recommendation: “Man’s Search for Meaning” – achieve happiness by dedicating yourself to someone or something.
  • “there’s a soul to a company” – JP
  • “In this business you have to be comfortable with bumpy flights” – JP on the life of an entrepreneur

After Josh shared his stories & wisdom, students asked some thought provoking questions.  Some that were especially thought provoking for me include:

  • How do you balance sharing information with your company & sharing information that scares people? (for instance, the company is low on cash, & you don’t want to scare people into thinking they’ll be cut)
    • Josh recommended “Just tell them”
    • In my own experiences an open book culture is a powerful way to get the team to take ownership & better know how they can impact the success of the business.  People cannot act in the best interests of the company when they don’t know what those interests are.  Being honest & open beats little to no transparency.  Be authentic. Don’t unpleasantly surprise your team & they won’t unpleasantly surprise you
  • For companies early on, low on resources, how do you build a fun team environment?
    • My thoughts: So you don’t have cash to take your entire team to Cedar Point, how do you still incorporate fun team activities (if that’s part of your culture)…do it within your means.  You don’t have to spend a ton of money (or any at all) to build culture through activities.  Going to a park & playing frisbee will cost you the price of the frisbee.  At Iorio’s we do team bonding activities when times are flush & when times are less cash rich.  It doesn’t matter.  Be creative & find a way to make it work.
  • How did you find the people you hired?
    • Josh brought in people he had worked with before.
    • If you don’t have that luxury & you’re starting for the first time, or you need to hire more people than you have previous colleagues, remember this – building your culture starts with your job posting & application.  What do I mean by this?  The language of your job posting & application sets a tone.  If you are a fun & creative company, make your job description & application fun & creative.  This is the best way to attract talent aligned with your culture & give you a great pool of candidates to hire from.

After Josh finished speaking, the discussion about culture & people continued.  A few nuggets of wisdom to share:

  • “Culture is based on 99% of what the CEO does & 1% on what he says” – Fry
  • “Culture is the single most important factor in recruiting & retaining key employees” – Fry
  • “Employee behavior consistent with the culture should be recognized” – Fry
  • CEO plans culture, lives it, reinforces it, manages it, tracks & measures it, modifies as needed
  • “Personnel selection is decisive. People are our most valuable capital” – Joseph Stalin
  • “as leadership changes, the effectiveness of people may also change”

And some questions that were asked:

  • Should vision statement be about 1 product (if company only has 1 product) or something bigger?
    • Tony thinks it should be bigger
    • I think a vision is big.  Your core vision for your company is that north star…what are you reaching for.  For instance, Disney’s vision is to “make people happy”.  At Iorio’s our vision is to “deliver sweetness”.  These visions are big & broad.  I have found it helpful to also write “vision statements” that may reflect more tangible, shorter & longer term visions for specific aspects of the company.  A vision statement that is written out could be short term focused & looking out at 1 year from now & that may only include 1 product.  I recommend writing vision statements when launching a new product, taking on a new initiative, starting a new company etc…answer questions like “what does this product/company look like?” “how do our customers respond?” “what are the challenges we are overcoming?”  paint a picture of the future.  Put yourself in the future.  A vision statement should be written as if you are in the future.  For more visioning tips I recommend reading some of Ari Weinzweig’s tips on visioning. I, and many others, have learned from him.
  • What do you think comes first, the culture or the people?
    • Tom mentioned that half the people he meets that start companies don’t think about the culture, even if, as an investor, he hints at its importance.
    • I think culture is an iterative process, especially early on.  Like product iteration.  Create culture consciously. Bring on people that align with that culture, learn from them & team dynamics, iterate culture consciously, bring on more people. Rinse & repeat.

Bottom line: Create culture consciously & continually.  All this talk about culture in class has me enthused about learning more & sharing more about what I’ve learned about culture.  What questions do you have?  What would you like to learn about culture & people?

Venture on,

MEL aka Venture Gal